The Maryland General Assembly is exploring the possibility of removing caps on noneconomic damages payouts.
In Maryland, noneconomic damages are payments for intangible losses, like pain and suffering, intentional infliction of emotional distress, and loss of care, support or enjoyment of life.
The state imposes caps on how much money can be collected via noneconomic damages. As of Oct. 1, Maryland’s rests at $980,000.
Juries are not informed of these caps when deliberating. If a jury awards noneconomic damages in an amount that is greater than the cap, the court is required to reduce the amount to adhere to the legal limit.
“Decades ago, insurance companies told the legislatures of this body and many other states that caps on pain and suffering damages were necessary to keep insurance affordable, doctors practicing and hospitals open,” Emily Malarkey, a legislative chair with the Maryland Association for Justice and cofounder of Malarkey Perlin, LLC, said before the House Judiciary Committee on Tuesday. “Many states have since learned that caps do none of those things and have either abandoned or severely limited them. Not so here.”
But Joseph Johnston of the Maryland Defense Counsel worries what repealing the cap on noneconomic damages could mean for medical malpractice cases.
Johnston, who specializes in medical malpractice defense at Goodell DeVries, said removing the cap in severe catastrophic injury cases would “make it considerably more expensive to settle those cases,” which often target hospitals in birth injury lawsuits.
In those cases, Johnston said Tuesday, plaintiffs’ attorneys hire economists and life care planners to testify.
“We are now routinely seeing life care plans in the tens of millions of dollars, and those damages are uncapped,” he said. “Removing the noneconomic damages cap in those cases would only compound the problem that hospitals in Maryland already face in defending against those lawsuits.”
A bill to nix these caps was sponsored in the 2026 legislative session by Sen. Jeffrey Waldstreicher, D-Montgomery, but it died in committee.
Malarkey said Maryland’s “neighbors prove that repeal will not send (liability insurance) premiums soaring,” noting that Washington, D.C., which has never had a cap, has two insurers that charge within 1% of their Maryland rates and another that charges 19% less.
“Maryland’s cap does not protect doctors or hospitals,” she said. “It ships the cost from insurance companies to patients. The market doesn’t need it, and it’s time for it to go.”
State lawmakers return to Annapolis for the next General Assembly session Jan. 13.