Maryland weighs lifting its damages cap

As states debate how much juries should be able to award in personal injury cases, Maryland’s long-standing limits on noneconomic damages is facing renewed pressure, threatening the stability of the medical liability environment.

The Daily Record reports that Maryland lawmakers are considering removing the reasonable limits on noneconomic damages, typically for things like “pain and suffering,” which are currently set at $980,000. A 2026 bill to raise the limit, sponsored by Sen. Jeffrey Waldstreicher, died in committee, but the issue is expected to return when lawmakers reconvene early next year.

Joseph Johnston, a defense attorney at Goodell DeVries speaking on behalf of the Maryland Defense Counsel, warned that the state’s damages exposure is already growing in other ways. “We are now routinely seeing life care plans in the tens of millions of dollars, and those damages are uncapped,” he said. “Removing the noneconomic damages cap in those cases would only compound the problem that hospitals in Maryland already face in defending against those lawsuits.”

While supporters of the repeal point to Washington, D.C. as a comparable model with no limits on noneconomic damages but similar liability insurance rates, the debate continues based on past precedent. Physician and hospital advocates warn that weakening reasonable limits on non-economic damages could raise costs and push settlements higher, straining patient access to care and affordability.

Click here to read more about the debate over Maryland’s noneconomic damages cap and the negative impact it would have on health care costs in the state.


Modest rate increases mask reality of liability climate

Medical liability insurance premiums may look steady on the surface, but the financial picture for the carriers hides a more complicated story.

According to Medical Liability Monitor’s 2026 Annual Rate Survey, medical professional liability rates rose an average of 1.8% in 2026, slightly below the 1.9% increase recorded in 2025. The survey tracks rates for internal medicine, general surgery, and obstetrics/gynecology at $1 million per claim and $3 million annually, as of July 1, 2026. While about half of the rates remained unchanged, nearly 40% increased year over year – costs that are expected to be further passed on to patient populations.

Additionally, the industry’s combined ratio – a measure of whether insurers are paying out more in claims and expenses than they collect in premiums – worsened to 107.4% in 2025, its 12th consecutive year of underwriting losses.

Medical Liability Monitor points to a disconnect between rising liability costs and restrained premium increases. It notes that competition for market share has led some insurers to cut prices, which raises questions about whether current pricing is sustainable.

Given that insurers are in their second decade of absorbing underwriting losses, the strain is only increasing, raising the prospect of future premium pressure for the physicians and health care organizations who depend on stable, affordable coverage.

To read more about the 2026 Annual Rate Survey and the pricing pressures facing medical liability insurers, click here.  

New Mexico tries to win back its doctors

In New Mexico, the fallout from medical lawsuit abuse shows up in hospital insurance bills and dwindling doctors.

Union County General Hospital, the only hospital in its county, was recently turned down by more than 40 insurers until two would agree to cover the hospital – charging nearly 500% more than its previous carrier. The hospital’s options were to accept the increase, or close.

“Without this hospital, people will die,” said Tammie Chavez, Chief Executive Officer for Union County General Hospital.

Across the state, the costs of providing health care have been unsustainable, leading practices to close and providers to leave. New Mexico had a net loss of 248 doctors from 2019 to 2024, the only state to lose physicians, with some of the highest liability lawsuit payout rates in the country.  

Earlier this month, lawmakers heard whether a recent fix is working. House Bill 99, signed in March, places reasonable limits on the damages juries can award and treats one injury as a single claim. Christian Myers, chief actuary at the state Office of the Superintendent of Insurance, told the committee, “We anticipate (House Bill 99) will lower prices for providers and hospitals for medical malpractice in the long-term,” though the full effect is three to four years off, Source NM reports.

The early signs are encouraging. Troy Clark, president and CEO of the New Mexico Hospital Association, said, “We actually have seen the exodus start to slow down.”

However, the work is far from over, with continuous attempts to undermine sound liability policy both in New Mexico and across the U.S. Click here to read more about whether New Mexico’s reform can bring doctors – and reasonable insurance costs – back to the state.